Part of a path: I just bought a boat

1 of

1 of

1 of

5

5

5

· I just bought a boat

· I just bought a boat

Questions to Ask When Buying a Used Boat on the Great Lakes

The boat can show you how she looks today. Only the seller can tell you how she was treated. The questions to ask, and what the answers tell you.

Captain Tom Ketelhut

Captain Tom Ketelhut

USCG Master since 2009

USCG Master since 2009

USCG Master since 2009

· 6 min read

· 6 min read

6 min read

Two hands shaking

A used boat comes with whatever records the last owner bothered to keep. Sometimes that’s a binder with every receipt since she was new. Sometimes it’s a shrug.

That’s why the questions to ask when buying a used boat are mostly about the seller, the history and the systems. The boat in front of you can show you how she looks today. It can’t tell you how she was treated. The first time I bought a boat, I’d already spent six years working in a marina, and there were still questions I didn’t think to ask. These are the ones I’d ask now, roughly in this order, and they’re the same ones I walk through with buyers as part of boat purchase help.

Start with the seller

Most buyers start with the boat. Start with the person selling her.

Why are you selling? Almost nobody asks it straight out, and the answer matters. Moving up, slowing down, moving away, kids grown and gone: that’s life, and it says nothing bad about the boat. “She’s more work than I want” isn’t a dealbreaker either, but something has been pushing the owner toward the exit, and you want to know what it is.

How long have you had her, and who owned her before? One careful owner for a long stretch is about the best history a used boat can have. Three owners in five years deserves an explanation. If the seller bought her from someone they know, ask for an introduction. Sellers with nothing to hide usually make one.

Where did she live, and who worked on her? A boat that spent ten seasons at the same marina, with the same yard doing the work, is a known quantity, and that yard will usually talk to you. A boat that moved around, or got serviced by whoever was handy, means more digging.

On the Great Lakes, add one more: where did she spend the winters? Heated storage, a cold building and shrink-wrap out in the yard are three different stories about freeze risk and sun. Ask who winterized her and whether there’s a record of it. A rushed winterization tends to show up at spring launch, and if you bought her, that spring is yours.

Then the history

Can I see the service records? A boat that’s been looked after comes with a folder, a binder or a shoebox of receipts, and the owner hands it over without a pause. Spotty records usually mean spotty attention. You don’t need to be a mechanic to read a service log. You only need to see whether one exists and whether it shows steady work: oil, impellers, fuel filters, anodes.

Any accidents, groundings, major repairs or insurance claims? Ask, then ask again in different words. Sellers don’t always volunteer a hard grounding or a big hull repair, and some of them honestly didn’t think it was a big deal.

Has she ever been in salt water? Up here it’s a real question. Some Great Lakes boats spent years in Florida or on the East Coast, and salt is harder on engines, fasteners and wiring than fresh water is. That doesn’t rule a boat out, but she’s a different boat, and the price should say so. If she’s still down south, getting her home is its own project.

How many hours, and how did they get there? Everybody asks the number. Ask how it was built: steady weekends with a service every year, or a few hard seasons with long gaps between. Then ask whether the services the engine manufacturer calls for were done on schedule, and ask to see them.

A boat with more hours and complete records is often a better buy than one with low hours and none. The meter tells you how long the engines ran. The records tell you how they were treated.

Check the paperwork before you fall in love

Before money moves, make sure the boat at the dock is the boat on the paper. Find the hull identification number. Federal rules put it on the starboard side of the transom, near the top, with a duplicate hidden somewhere inside. Check it against the title or the Coast Guard documentation.

If she’s documented, the Coast Guard records mortgages against her, and its documentation center will let you request an abstract of title before you close. Either way, get the seller’s promise that she’s free and clear in writing. The BoatUS sample purchase agreement has that clause, along with the one that makes the sale contingent on an acceptable survey and sea trial.

Look at the systems

You’re not doing the surveyor’s job at a showing, but you should walk away knowing whether anything surprised you.

The generator. Ask the hours, the last service, and whether it actually gets used. One that hasn’t run in years is an unknown.

The electronics. Ask the age of the plotter, radar, autopilot and VHF. An older unit can still work and still be due for replacement, and that belongs in the price.

The hull. Walk it slowly. Look for cracks, soft spots and old repairs, and ask about any work done on the hull or the transom.

The fuel. Ask when the tanks were last looked at, and on a gas boat, how the fuel was handled over the winter.

The engine compartment. Open it. A clean, dry bilge, batteries that are recent and tied down, and wiring that’s neat and labeled tell you what the places you can’t see probably look like.

Questions to hold until after the survey

Some questions cost you leverage if you ask them too early.

“What’s your bottom line?” before the survey tells the seller you’re negotiating without information. Wait until you have some. “Is the price firm?” gets you nowhere, because it isn’t, and everybody knows it isn’t. And on a cruising boat, “How fast does she go?” is the wrong question. Range, fuel burn and comfort at cruising speed are what you’ll live with.

The survey is where the deal gets made

Make your offer subject to a survey and a sea trial, and hire the surveyor yourself. A surveyor who works for you is the whole point, and what a marine survey covers walks through what each kind catches and how to pick one. Every survey finds something, because every boat has something. The work is sorting the dealbreakers from the negotiating points and the normal wear, and that’s where most of the price conversation happens.

Then run the sea trial like an evaluation, not a ride. Most buyers spend weeks looking at boats and an afternoon on the survey and the sea trial. Turn that around.

The short list.

Take it to the showing.

  1. Why are you selling?

  2. How long have you had her, and who owned her before?

  3. Where was she kept and serviced, and where did she spend the winters?

  4. Can I see the service and winterization records?

  5. Any accidents, groundings, major repairs or insurance claims?

  6. Has she ever been in salt water?

  7. How were the engine hours put on, and were the scheduled services done?

  8. How old are the generator, electronics and batteries?

  9. Does the hull identification number match the paperwork, and is she free and clear?

  10. Is there anything you’d want me to know?

The last question

End with that last one, asked plainly: “Is there anything you’d want me to know?” It gives the seller an opening to mention what they might otherwise leave out. Some will take it. Some won’t. Either way, nobody can say later that you didn’t ask.

A list is a start, but a specific boat goes faster with someone who has bought, sold, delivered and maintained them. I ride along on sea trials, read survey reports with buyers, and give a straight answer on whether the boat in front of you is the right one. If you’re shopping a boat show or already have a boat in mind, a quick call is the place to start. If you’ve already closed, start with the new-owner list instead.

Captain Tom Ketelhut

WRITTEN BY

Captain Tom Ketelhut

USCG Master since 2009: 100 GT Great Lakes, 50 GT Near Coastal. Home port Grosse Ile, Michigan; deliveries and coaching from Lake Erie to Lake Huron, and in Florida.

WHERE TO NEXT

Keep going

UP NEXT IN YOUR PATH ·

2 of

5

7 min read ·

I just bought a boat

Continue the path

THE SERVICE THAT HELPS

A USCG Master runs the sea trial with you and helps you decide before you close.

Get the next piece by email.